Understanding the Mystique of the Black Belt in Martial Arts

Introduction

In this post, we will explore the question, "What is a black belt?" I will explain the lore behind it, what the layman thinks, how different martial arts perceive it, and what I believe a black belt truly represents.

The Lore of the Black Belt

The legend states that practitioners wore a white belt while training, and as it became dirtier over time, it transformed into a black belt. While this story is captivating, the real history is a bit different.

The year was 1883, and in Japan, Master Jigoro Kano, the founder of Judo, decided to adopt a ranking system similar to that of other sports. He introduced two belts: white for beginners and black for advanced students. The practitioners wore thick belts called "Obi," which helped secure their kimonos or held a sword. It wasn't until the 1930s and 1940s that Europeans added additional colors like orange, yellow, purple, blue, and red. I apologize if this is less mystical than the origin story.

The Layman's Perspective on Black Belts

As someone who has been involved in martial arts since I was five years old, I understand that many people perceive black belts through a limited lens. For the average person, a black belt represents a credential—akin to a degree from college. It suggests that the holder knows how to fight. However, numerous videos on YouTube demonstrate that many black belts struggle in real fighting scenarios.

Moreover, some black belts are uncoordinated or even overweight. The expectation that black belts are inherently humble or “good people” is often proven wrong. I have encountered arrogant individuals who sport a black belt, just as I have met humble white belts eager to learn. Ultimately, a belt's color does not determine a person's character; actions do.

The Martial Arts Community's Viewpoint

Within the broad community of martial arts, opinions differ about the respectability of various belts. Some belts are held in high regard, while others are seen as less credible. Much of this perspective hinges on the success of martial artists in MMA competitions.

You might be wondering which black belts are viewed as less credible. Notably, styles like Taekwondo, Aikido, and Kung Fu have often been criticized. Two decades ago, Karate would have made this list. However, recent success of certain Karate practitioners in UFC has shifted this perception, highlighting that the reputation of Karate now depends on the specific style practiced.

In contrast, Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ) black belts are generally highly regarded. Muay Thai and wrestling also earn respect, although they lack a formal belt ranking system. This collective opinion is drawn from a wide range of martial artists, not just individuals practicing one discipline.

What Does a Black Belt Mean to Me?

My perspective on black belts consists of two sides: my inward view and my outward view.

Inwardly, I see my black belt simply as a tool to keep my gi together. My caliber as a fighter should stand independently from the color of my belt, just as my character should not be defined by it.

Outwardly, a black belt signifies a person's commitment to a martial art over a substantial period. It does not guarantee fighting ability or imply that the individual is inherently virtuous. However, generally, it indicates that the person has dedicated at least five years to consistent practice—whether that practice was easy or challenging, it required effort nonetheless.

The Essence of a Black Belt

The phrase "the journey defines the black belt" resonates with me. Achieving a black belt often involves overcoming personal struggles and challenges. This journey shapes the practitioner, making them who they are. A black belt is not just a symbol but a reflection of dedication, resilience, and growth.

Conclusion

If there is one takeaway from this post, it is this: The belt does not make the person; the person makes the belt.

If you are interested in obtaining a black belt merely to keep your gi together, consider signing up for your free trial class here. Thank you for reading, and I encourage you to leave a comment sharing what a black belt means to you.